End of life care in England: a briefing paper | IPPR
This paper provides a brief summary of issues around end of life care including the impact of location on the quality and cost of care; analyses data on the current location and cost of end of life care in England; and appraises the current policy agenda in this area, suggesting key areas where improvements should be made.
Macmillan Cancer Support reports that a need for patients with a diagnosis of cancer to ‘fight’ and remain positive could be having a negative effect on people living with the disease. Over 75 per cent of people with cancer have thought about the possibility that they might die from the disease, however the report identifies a number of barriers to them being able to discuss this honestly.
According to health and social care professionals, one of the largest obstacles is within the pressure to stay positive and support people to fight cancer, even in the face of a terminal diagnosis.
Macmillan Cancer Support indicates that while it is a commonly held belief that describing people with cancer as ‘fighters’, keeps a person’s spirits high and instils in them a sense that the professionals supporting them are helping them to ‘fight the battle’. While some may find this language helpful, Missed Opportunities highlights the challenging contradiction of this fighting talk for people at the end of their lives.
Key findings from the report include:
The perceived need to ‘fight’ cancer often means people with a terminal diagnosis aren’t getting the right support to plan for end of life
More than one in four people with cancer (28%) have difficulty talking honestly about their feelings around cancer
Gulf in communication means thousands of people with cancer unnecessarily die in hospital against their wishes
Advance Care Planning, discussing end of life wishes, can significantly improve end of life experiences
Objectives Little is known about the cost of a palliative care approach in the UK, and there is an absence of robust activity and unit cost data. The aim of this study was to review evidence on the costs of specialist and generalist palliative care in the UK, and to explore different approaches used for capturing activity and unit cost data.
Methods A systematic review with narrative synthesis. Four electronic databases were searched for empirical literature on the costs of a palliative care approach in the UK, and a narrative method was used to synthesise the data.
Results Ten papers met our inclusion criteria. The studies displayed significant variation in their estimates of the cost of palliative care, therefore it was not possible to present an accurate aggregate cost of palliative care in the UK. The majority of studies explored costs from a National Health Service perspective and only two studies included informal care costs. Approaches to estimating activity and costs varied. Particular challenges were noted with capturing activity and cost data for hospice and informal care.
Conclusion The data are limited, and the heterogeneity is such that it is not possible to provide an aggregate cost of palliative care in the UK. It is notable that the costs of hospice care and informal care are often neglected in economic studies. Further work is needed to address methodological and practical challenges in order to gain a more complete understanding of the costs of palliative care.
Study highlights the need for improved care, communication and further research to establish which treatments are most effective within a palliative care population | BMC Paliiative Care
Symptom management is an essential aspect of palliative and end-of-life care, but evidence suggests that patients’ symptoms may not always be relieved, causing significant harm to patients and magnifying their relatives’ distress. A growing body of evidence focuses on symptom management at the end-of-life, but research funding for palliative care remains disproportionately low. It is therefore crucial that research funding is targeted at areas of importance to patients and relatives. The Palliative and end-of-life care Priority Setting Partnership (PeolcPSP) undertook a UK-wide free-text survey to establish research priorities within palliative and end-of-life care and disseminated its results in 2015. Much of the data were related more broadly to personal perceptions and experiences rather than specific research questions. The aim of this article is to report on a supplementary analysis exploring the experiences and questions of PeolcPSP survey respondents regarding symptoms, hydration and nutrition.
The PeolcPSP data (n = 1403) were coded by a team of qualitative researchers in a supplementary analysis. There were 190 responses that related to symptoms, nutrition and hydration. The data were analysed thematically using Braun and Clarke’s approach.
Five themes were identified: pain, breathlessness, agitation, nutrition and hydration. The majority of responses related to symptoms that were sub-optimally managed, in particular pain. Nutrition and hydration were of significant concern, particularly for carers. Overall, respondents consistently asked about the most effective, evidence-based methods for managing symptoms and suggested areas where further research is necessary.
This study highlights the perceptions and experiences of patients, families and professionals within palliative care, highlighting the need for improved care, communication and further research to establish which treatments are most effective within a palliative care population. This is essential to reduce harm and distress for patients and families.
My future wishes: Advance Care Planning (ACP) for people with dementia in all settings | NHS England | Alzheimer’s Society | tide
The guide provides signposting, information and support for colleagues in health, social and community care settings, around advance care planning for people living with dementia. It identifies key actions from the point of an initial diagnosis of dementia through to the advanced condition, in order to highlight and prompt best practice irrespective of care setting.
It also considers situations where it has not been possible to initiate an ACP / future wishes conversation early and provides some tips on how to manage this.
The aim of this resource is to help practitioners, providers and health and social care commissioners:
create opportunities for people living with dementia to develop an ACP through
initiating and / or opening up conversations;
ensure advance care planning is fully embedded in wider inclusive, personalised care and support planning for dementia;
ensure people living with dementia have the same equal opportunities as those
diagnosed with other life limiting conditions / diseases, in terms of accessing palliative care services / support.
NIHR | March 2018 | Why the world needs to get ready for more people dying
“We are living longer and dying slower, but how well prepared are we for the challenges that come with that?”writes Dr Katherine Sleeman on the NIHR’s blog.
A swathe of medical and technological advances during the last century increased life expectancy dramatically by about 30 years rising to 83 for females and 79 for males, the consequence it meant individuals ‘delayed dying’. According to Dr Sleeman we are now at ‘tipping point’ as mortality rates are currently at half a million people a year in England, but this will be raised by about 20% in total over the next 20 years, until an extra 100,000 people are dying each year.
While palliative care is now appreciated as working best when used early and alongside other medical care; it receives, even in countries with high GDP, low levels of research funding. In England this is less than 1 % (0.5%) of the medical research funding allotted to palliative care and end of life research, at a time that Dr Sleeman recognises that demand for end of life care will increase by nearly 40 per cent in the next twenty years. Although advances have ‘changed how we die [they have]not changed the fact that it will happen to all of us.’
Schmid, W., Rosland, J. H., von Hofacker, S., Hunskår, I., & Bruvik, F | (2018) |
Patient’s and health care provider’s perspectives on music therapy in palliative care–an integrative review | BMC palliative care | Vol. 17. | 32 | Doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12904-018-0286-4
An integrative review analysed the literature on music therapy in English, German or Scandinavian languages published in peer-reviewed journals between November 1978 and December 2016. The criteria for inclusion was music therapy with adults in palliative care conducted by a certified music therapist. This systematic literature review identified 12 papers, three quarters of these had taken a quantitative and the remainder a qualitative approach.
The researchers aimed to identify and discuss the perspectives of both patients and health care providers on music therapy’s (MT) impact in palliative care. They utilised an inductive, qualitative approach to analyse and categorize the data.
Although the majority of the quantitative studies, (7 out of 9) investigated pain as an outcome they also presented the positive effects of MT. The investigators conclude that a major theme in both types of research is a psycho-physiological change through music therapy. The study outcomes of individual MT as having a positive effect on some symptoms, as well as improving quality of life in the setting. While this review adds to existing research, it is an area that requires further research, and would particularly benefit from studies employing a mixed-methods approach.